So what do you think of when you think of the word 'independence'?
It has now become one of the words in my vocabulary that I greatly despise however, at one point I held it as one of my strongest values.
Actually, there I go talking in past tense again, if I am honest with myself somewhere in me I am still extremely stubborn and want nothing more than independence. However, I am right now in a fight to end the fight for independence if that makes any sense.
Now just to clarify something, for me independence always meant just completely relying on God for everything but never having to be dependent on another human being. Me and Jesus could go anywhere and I did not 'need' any one else. I am not exactly sure where this value kicked in so strongly for me but I do believe it is a pretty strong American value in general. In regards to the eating disorder thing, for the longest time I believed just locking myself in a room with a bible and Jesus would get me out of it.
I have just viewed it as a huge sign of weakness of faith to have to ask people for anything....whether it was financial support, material needs, emotional needs, spiritual help...or even a simple hug when I was having a bad day. Well, God has begun to humble me a little bit on this because in the past year I have been forced to rely on other people for all of these.
However, with the help of my mentor back at Houghton I am slowly beginning to realize that this is not a value at all but a curse. Christine, who has traveled the world as a missionary, told me that if you step foot into another culture you won’t see it at all. It really is an American value, not a biblical one. It is ok to seek support from other human beings. Just simply being a part of the body of Christ we were made to depend on each other. A hand can not say to a foot, "I do not need you."
The following is a journal entry from when I went to visit Christine back in February:
"Christine showed me that it is actually healthy to break down that need for independence that our culture strives for and to become weak. We all go through some extremely trying times in life where we just need the church to hold us for awhile until we are healed. It doesn’t have to be a permanent thing. When I’m healed, I will likely get the opportunity to hold someone else. And frankly, that vision in itself sounds a whole lot more freeing than the independence thing that was just holding me in complete bondage. "
"It really has been my pride holding me back and I just need to be humbled to a lower level. Humbled to the point that I actually have to rely on other people to take care of me for awhile and that is beyond terrifying but I think I will come out a ‘stronger’ person because of it. I also was explaining to Christine how I had a very hard time discerning truth from lies in my head, everything was all jumbled. She immediately said that is what community is for. If I just locked myself in a room with Jesus and a Bible, it is likely that those Ana lies would get the best of me."
" However, as I start talking my mind out with others, they can help me see truth. They can guide me in truth and tell me what are just the lies. She used the metaphor of brick-building. One brick does very little good but when you put them together, they make something beautiful."
"It’s not just a give give give thing to those who are less fortunate like I had been making Christianity out to be. I need to be willing to receive as well. As the old song goes, “Will you let me be your servant, let me be as Christ to you, pray that I might have the grace to let you be my servant too. The last part is the part that I have always had difficulty with. She told me that if my appendix burst, I would probably rely on others to help me so why is this different? And not only doctors, but friends and family would probably be around offering care and encouragement."
This remind me of what Hank at reunion once said..."If you need to go to the hospital bring a friend because it has been proven to help you heal faster."
I have no idea why this is so hard for me though. But in the readings I have done...it is common thread among most anorexics:
"The anorexic abhors her emotional neediness, and so will starve herself as a way of proclaiming, ‘Look how strong I am. I have no needs. I don’t need food. I don’t need anyone. I have triumphed over my weaknesses and I am in control.” ~French Toast for Breakfast
“People with eating problems often feel their emotional needs are repulsive and see their bodies as the external symbol for these shameful inner needs. ‘If I can control my body,’ they think, ‘then I can control my emotional neediness.’ Actually, many have no idea what their needs really are because everything has become so detoured through food. Others mistakenly consider their need for nurturing as selfish.” ~ French Toast For Breakfast
“When we stave, we become totally self-sufficient and do not have to rely or depend on others. We try to become invulnerable because a ‘rock feels no pain. And an island never cries.’ Only when we stop this emotional eating do we discover just how needy and vulnerable we really are, and that can be scary.” ~French Toast For Breakfast
I can relate with the above quotes all too well. I was in the mission to prove to the world that I could do everything by myself. I left my hometown and went off to college where I traveled great distances (both figurative and literal)...crossed the ocean to serve in Romania for a summer....moved to Boston to serve in the inner city. And as many know, I was about to head to Korea this summer for a year teaching position. However, my motives behind it were simply to prove to myself and to the world and to God that I could do it. I didn't know how just to sit still because my life over the past few years has been constantly trying to prove myself as that "island" who needs nobody.
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Tuesday, April 14, 2009
Stand in the Rain
She never slows down
She doesn't know why but
she knows that when
She's all alone feels
Like it's all coming down
She won't turn around
The shadows are long
And she fears if she cries
That first tear
The tears will not stop
Raining down
So stand in the rain
Stand your ground
Stand up when it's all crashing down
You stand through the pain
You won't drown
And one day what's lost can be found
You stand in the rain
She won't make a sound
Alone in this fight with herself
And the fears whispering
If she stands, she'll fall down
She wants to be found but
The only way out is through everything she's running from
Wants to give up and lie down
So stand in the rain
Stand your ground
Stand up when it's all crashing down
You stand through the pain
You won't drown
And one day what's lost can be found
You stand in the rain
~Superchick
She doesn't know why but
she knows that when
She's all alone feels
Like it's all coming down
She won't turn around
The shadows are long
And she fears if she cries
That first tear
The tears will not stop
Raining down
So stand in the rain
Stand your ground
Stand up when it's all crashing down
You stand through the pain
You won't drown
And one day what's lost can be found
You stand in the rain
She won't make a sound
Alone in this fight with herself
And the fears whispering
If she stands, she'll fall down
She wants to be found but
The only way out is through everything she's running from
Wants to give up and lie down
So stand in the rain
Stand your ground
Stand up when it's all crashing down
You stand through the pain
You won't drown
And one day what's lost can be found
You stand in the rain
~Superchick
Monday, April 13, 2009
Church...for the rest of us
"Reunion is a church. Not an event, not a place, but a community of people. We exist to help people find their way back to God through Jesus Christ. We are a people of faith, community, and generosity that seek to communicate God's story in the urban landscape of Boston. You'll find we're imperfect people striving to become more like Christ - not just on Sundays - but the way we live every day."
Now this is a complete 180 from the church I grew up in. It's not perfect - but that's why I like it.
At this church we worship Jesus. We fall, we stumble, we say the wrong things, we do the wrong things...we don't do 'enough'. But its ok. Jesus has got it covered. We also have fun (yea I know...complete pagans...I am over it though.)
It is not full of criticism and contempt. You don't have to be a member to have a voice (actually there is no membership). You don't have to dress up....I think you would be perfectly welcomed if you came in in pajamas. One of my favorite parts is that it is not even in a church building...we worship at a hotel, and its not necessarily the same hotel every week.
Within a month of attending this church, I found myself pouring that icky gross part of my life out on one of the staff members (what was funny was that I didn't know he was a staff member at the time)....asking in desperation for prayer. Never in my life have I been that comfortable talking to a complete stranger, let alone about something so shameful. I still don't know very many people, but I am beginning to realize that most if not all, accept me for who I am.
The people I do know are in my 'community group'. Unlike the church I grew up in, this church understands that following Jesus is so much more than listening to a sermon on Sunday morning. Church happens in community groups. They are small groups that meet in the houses of other people in the Reunion community.
“Community groups are places where the kingdom of God works out in the messiness around us.” ~ Reunion
I started attending Steve and Amy's community group back in September which at the time was a brand new group. I had no idea that at the start of this group Nathan, Danielle, Caleb, Kait, Seth, Amy, and Steve would become people that I felt more than comfortable confessing some of my worst struggles to. I think at this point I have poured out more of my soul to them than they ever needed to see and they know many things about me that my own family does not know.
Wednesday nights have become times to laugh and to pray and to have conversations about God and to have fun. They became very quicky for me a breather from the daily intensity of my own life as I slowly began to see that I am not alone. Although they may not be able to relate specifically with my struggles, all have known some sort of pain or brokenness. Basically they are real people...which are actually kind of hard to find these days! Recently we have started sharing our "stories" with one another which is a really cool way to learn about another person and at the same time to learn more about God as you see how He has worked in the life of that person. It gives the people who are listening the opportunity to appreciate that person and how they were created in all of their wonderful uniqueness. (Ok so at this point only one person has gone so far but we got the opportunity to appreciate the wonderful uniqueness of Nathan and look forward to hearing Seth's story on Wednesday!)
However, the part I like about community group the most is how I am slowly beginning to realize that my life can actually have some purpose. I don't feel at all like it is just me pouring my grossness out on others like I had to do with the counselors. I feel like I have something to offer the others in the group as well, even if that is just a listening ear. We are a community and the relationships are give and take.
Going back to Peter Block's definition of belonging and community,..."We are in community each time we find a place where we belong…belong is to be related and to be a part of something. It is membership, the experience of being at home in the broad sense of the phrase. It is the opposite of thinking that wherever I am, I would be better off somewhere else. Or that I am still forever wandering, looking for that place where I belong…to belong is to know, even in the middle of the night, that I am among friends.” Well I can say for sure that I know where I can find this belonging on Wednesday evenings and Sunday mornings (...it is just the rest of the week that I am having a little trouble figuring out).
I turned down the opportunity to have a paid flight back to Buffalo this year for Easter because I wanted to do Easter at 'home' this year. I wanted to be with my community. We had a good friday celebration with community group that I did not want to miss and there was something special about having Easter morning at the Hilton instead of the First Baptist Church of Akron...it was far less stressful and far more meaningful :)
However, as I am slowly beginning to find that place where I belong, I am realizing that I am probably not alone in this. Community group is great on Wednesday nights but I am becoming more and more passionate about the concept of belonging and community....for everyone, not just me, and being able to live this out on a daily basis.
The main reason I have decided to stay in Boston another year is simply because of this church (that and of course God giving strong whispers that I need to stop and stay still for awhile). It is home....no matter what is happening in my day to day life. Reunion has begun to give me that spark of hope that at many times I have felt like I have completely lost. The community of people there are beginning to show me truth again and leading me back to Jesus...the true Jesus.
Now this is a complete 180 from the church I grew up in. It's not perfect - but that's why I like it.
At this church we worship Jesus. We fall, we stumble, we say the wrong things, we do the wrong things...we don't do 'enough'. But its ok. Jesus has got it covered. We also have fun (yea I know...complete pagans...I am over it though.)
It is not full of criticism and contempt. You don't have to be a member to have a voice (actually there is no membership). You don't have to dress up....I think you would be perfectly welcomed if you came in in pajamas. One of my favorite parts is that it is not even in a church building...we worship at a hotel, and its not necessarily the same hotel every week.
Within a month of attending this church, I found myself pouring that icky gross part of my life out on one of the staff members (what was funny was that I didn't know he was a staff member at the time)....asking in desperation for prayer. Never in my life have I been that comfortable talking to a complete stranger, let alone about something so shameful. I still don't know very many people, but I am beginning to realize that most if not all, accept me for who I am.
The people I do know are in my 'community group'. Unlike the church I grew up in, this church understands that following Jesus is so much more than listening to a sermon on Sunday morning. Church happens in community groups. They are small groups that meet in the houses of other people in the Reunion community.
“Community groups are places where the kingdom of God works out in the messiness around us.” ~ Reunion
I started attending Steve and Amy's community group back in September which at the time was a brand new group. I had no idea that at the start of this group Nathan, Danielle, Caleb, Kait, Seth, Amy, and Steve would become people that I felt more than comfortable confessing some of my worst struggles to. I think at this point I have poured out more of my soul to them than they ever needed to see and they know many things about me that my own family does not know.
Wednesday nights have become times to laugh and to pray and to have conversations about God and to have fun. They became very quicky for me a breather from the daily intensity of my own life as I slowly began to see that I am not alone. Although they may not be able to relate specifically with my struggles, all have known some sort of pain or brokenness. Basically they are real people...which are actually kind of hard to find these days! Recently we have started sharing our "stories" with one another which is a really cool way to learn about another person and at the same time to learn more about God as you see how He has worked in the life of that person. It gives the people who are listening the opportunity to appreciate that person and how they were created in all of their wonderful uniqueness. (Ok so at this point only one person has gone so far but we got the opportunity to appreciate the wonderful uniqueness of Nathan and look forward to hearing Seth's story on Wednesday!)
However, the part I like about community group the most is how I am slowly beginning to realize that my life can actually have some purpose. I don't feel at all like it is just me pouring my grossness out on others like I had to do with the counselors. I feel like I have something to offer the others in the group as well, even if that is just a listening ear. We are a community and the relationships are give and take.
Going back to Peter Block's definition of belonging and community,..."We are in community each time we find a place where we belong…belong is to be related and to be a part of something. It is membership, the experience of being at home in the broad sense of the phrase. It is the opposite of thinking that wherever I am, I would be better off somewhere else. Or that I am still forever wandering, looking for that place where I belong…to belong is to know, even in the middle of the night, that I am among friends.” Well I can say for sure that I know where I can find this belonging on Wednesday evenings and Sunday mornings (...it is just the rest of the week that I am having a little trouble figuring out).
I turned down the opportunity to have a paid flight back to Buffalo this year for Easter because I wanted to do Easter at 'home' this year. I wanted to be with my community. We had a good friday celebration with community group that I did not want to miss and there was something special about having Easter morning at the Hilton instead of the First Baptist Church of Akron...it was far less stressful and far more meaningful :)
However, as I am slowly beginning to find that place where I belong, I am realizing that I am probably not alone in this. Community group is great on Wednesday nights but I am becoming more and more passionate about the concept of belonging and community....for everyone, not just me, and being able to live this out on a daily basis.
The main reason I have decided to stay in Boston another year is simply because of this church (that and of course God giving strong whispers that I need to stop and stay still for awhile). It is home....no matter what is happening in my day to day life. Reunion has begun to give me that spark of hope that at many times I have felt like I have completely lost. The community of people there are beginning to show me truth again and leading me back to Jesus...the true Jesus.
Sunday, April 12, 2009
Church...eh
First of all HAPPY EASTER.
Holidays are really just not that great of times for me although I look forward to them so much. I normally give myself permission to eat sweets that I have deprived myself of for so long then eat way too much and wake up the next morning convinced that I have gained 30 pounds.
But enough of that...I have begun to evaluate my view of the church this past year a lot...especially the past few months. So I thought I might reflect a little on my church background and how it has affected the way I look at the Christian church body as a whole...and in some ways as I hinted at before, the way I look at my own body.
A lot of the 'stereotypes' that people in America hold of the church, I have realized that I hold on a subconscious level as well...and I grew up in the church. Stereotypes like that Christians are judgemental and non accepting of differences. People put on a facade of being perfect...non Christians don't go to church because they feel that they are not good enough. Many people belive that the church is hypocritical.
I grew up in a very conservative Baptist church. I learned about the "Bible School Jesus" and "Middle Class Jesus" that we learned about in Reunion a few weeks ago. Jesus was presented as always smiling and happy. I was taught to be happy too. I was told that I was a sinner that I needed to repent but once I did life would be golden. Although they never came right out and said it, it was basically the health and wealth gospel. If you do good...good things will happen to you.
This was/is a church strongly rooted in tradition. Lived under the theory, "We have always done it that way before so why should we change it now." My parents grew up and met in this church, my grandparents on both sides grew up in this church, and my great grandparents as well. (That is a lot of family tradition in one building). My parents and my two living grandmothers still go there...leaving the church is just not an option.
I must say that I am grateful that I moved. But before I left, I was by far the youngest attendee and member of the church (My parents would probably be the next oldest). 95% of the church is above the age of 70. And although this may sound harsh, it is nothing but a building. It is the gossip center of our small town. My parents do there best along with a few others to try to hold it together and try to get people back to thinking about why we go to church to begin with...but they are so stuck in their rut and have no desire to get out.
And because I was the youngest member of this congregation (oh I should mention of about 30 people)...I was put on a pedestal. I heard constantly, "you are such a good person and you come from such a good family." Once they found out that I wanted to be a missionary this only increased by 100% (they actually support me as a 'missionary'...which isn't necessarily a bad thing...when I went to Romania they were extraordinarily helpful) However, all that goes through my mind is "if they really knew who I was, they would not be this kind."
Grace was something that was not heavily preached. Again, although no direct messages were on it, you got the feeling that it was by 'being good' and 'doing good' that you would be getting to heaven. Perfection was the standard and anyone who fell short was highly criticized (but don't worry, rarely to your face). There was a short period of time that a single mother and her daughter began going to our church. I was helping out at a church luncheon one day and the conversations that were going on about this mother made me ashamed to call myself a Christian if that is what a Christian was.
Good christians came to church every sunday, if you weren't there you would be sure that someone would be taking note. Good christians don't get divorced. Good Christians don't have sex before marriage. Good Christians don't drink alcohol. Good Christians always have a smile on their face. Good Christians give 10% of their money to the church, but still will have enough left to live comfortably in a middle class home. Good Christians never swear. Good Christians don't watch movies or tv shows like that. Good Christians are clean. Good Christians are always happy because they have Jesus in their hearts.
oops. Yup i failed. Maybe I can hide a little longer. They will never have to know the true me. Drug addictions, pornography, marital problems, alcoholism, abortion,...eating disorders....were never talked about in this church because they didn't happen. These were the problems of the outsiders. If I were to tell anyone in this church that I have struggled with anorexia (and there are some people in the church that I highly respect and still communicate with through snail mail)...I would be immediately rejected and my family's good name would be put to shame.
In college I got a small amount of freedom from this. I went to a Christian college. I learned more about Jesus and grace than I ever knew before. I found a loving community - far from perfect - but loving. Real issues began to get talked about and brokenness of others was accepted...however, when you are surrounded by other Christians that all seem 'good', it almost gets competive. It is not human nature to want to share your brokeness so you don't...you help others in their brokeness but never reveal that you carry your own baggage. I learned to be extremely non judgemental of others, but never learned this for myself. Everyone else was good and wonderful and did great things for the kingdom of God...but not me.
Somewhere along the way, I started hating myself for not being perfect...for not measuring up to the 'good christian' standards. I started hating my body. It didn't look like the supermodels you see on tv or in magazines. But maybe it could...if I just tried a little harder...
Little did I realize at the time, but once I moved to Boston, attending a church with the slogan of "Church for the rest of us" might be the start to healing some of those deep ingrained beliefs of goodness and perfection and how that relates to God.....
To be continued.
Holidays are really just not that great of times for me although I look forward to them so much. I normally give myself permission to eat sweets that I have deprived myself of for so long then eat way too much and wake up the next morning convinced that I have gained 30 pounds.
But enough of that...I have begun to evaluate my view of the church this past year a lot...especially the past few months. So I thought I might reflect a little on my church background and how it has affected the way I look at the Christian church body as a whole...and in some ways as I hinted at before, the way I look at my own body.
A lot of the 'stereotypes' that people in America hold of the church, I have realized that I hold on a subconscious level as well...and I grew up in the church. Stereotypes like that Christians are judgemental and non accepting of differences. People put on a facade of being perfect...non Christians don't go to church because they feel that they are not good enough. Many people belive that the church is hypocritical.
I grew up in a very conservative Baptist church. I learned about the "Bible School Jesus" and "Middle Class Jesus" that we learned about in Reunion a few weeks ago. Jesus was presented as always smiling and happy. I was taught to be happy too. I was told that I was a sinner that I needed to repent but once I did life would be golden. Although they never came right out and said it, it was basically the health and wealth gospel. If you do good...good things will happen to you.
This was/is a church strongly rooted in tradition. Lived under the theory, "We have always done it that way before so why should we change it now." My parents grew up and met in this church, my grandparents on both sides grew up in this church, and my great grandparents as well. (That is a lot of family tradition in one building). My parents and my two living grandmothers still go there...leaving the church is just not an option.
I must say that I am grateful that I moved. But before I left, I was by far the youngest attendee and member of the church (My parents would probably be the next oldest). 95% of the church is above the age of 70. And although this may sound harsh, it is nothing but a building. It is the gossip center of our small town. My parents do there best along with a few others to try to hold it together and try to get people back to thinking about why we go to church to begin with...but they are so stuck in their rut and have no desire to get out.
And because I was the youngest member of this congregation (oh I should mention of about 30 people)...I was put on a pedestal. I heard constantly, "you are such a good person and you come from such a good family." Once they found out that I wanted to be a missionary this only increased by 100% (they actually support me as a 'missionary'...which isn't necessarily a bad thing...when I went to Romania they were extraordinarily helpful) However, all that goes through my mind is "if they really knew who I was, they would not be this kind."
Grace was something that was not heavily preached. Again, although no direct messages were on it, you got the feeling that it was by 'being good' and 'doing good' that you would be getting to heaven. Perfection was the standard and anyone who fell short was highly criticized (but don't worry, rarely to your face). There was a short period of time that a single mother and her daughter began going to our church. I was helping out at a church luncheon one day and the conversations that were going on about this mother made me ashamed to call myself a Christian if that is what a Christian was.
Good christians came to church every sunday, if you weren't there you would be sure that someone would be taking note. Good christians don't get divorced. Good Christians don't have sex before marriage. Good Christians don't drink alcohol. Good Christians always have a smile on their face. Good Christians give 10% of their money to the church, but still will have enough left to live comfortably in a middle class home. Good Christians never swear. Good Christians don't watch movies or tv shows like that. Good Christians are clean. Good Christians are always happy because they have Jesus in their hearts.
oops. Yup i failed. Maybe I can hide a little longer. They will never have to know the true me. Drug addictions, pornography, marital problems, alcoholism, abortion,...eating disorders....were never talked about in this church because they didn't happen. These were the problems of the outsiders. If I were to tell anyone in this church that I have struggled with anorexia (and there are some people in the church that I highly respect and still communicate with through snail mail)...I would be immediately rejected and my family's good name would be put to shame.
In college I got a small amount of freedom from this. I went to a Christian college. I learned more about Jesus and grace than I ever knew before. I found a loving community - far from perfect - but loving. Real issues began to get talked about and brokenness of others was accepted...however, when you are surrounded by other Christians that all seem 'good', it almost gets competive. It is not human nature to want to share your brokeness so you don't...you help others in their brokeness but never reveal that you carry your own baggage. I learned to be extremely non judgemental of others, but never learned this for myself. Everyone else was good and wonderful and did great things for the kingdom of God...but not me.
Somewhere along the way, I started hating myself for not being perfect...for not measuring up to the 'good christian' standards. I started hating my body. It didn't look like the supermodels you see on tv or in magazines. But maybe it could...if I just tried a little harder...
Little did I realize at the time, but once I moved to Boston, attending a church with the slogan of "Church for the rest of us" might be the start to healing some of those deep ingrained beliefs of goodness and perfection and how that relates to God.....
To be continued.
Saturday, April 11, 2009
Community ramblings
Apparently I have a lot to say about this topic because I am choosing to ramble on just for a little longer.
I actually wrote the following awhile back in the midst of the counselor crisis...so some of it may be overlapping a little bit of what I have already said...
It might be slightly even more intense than normal entries because I don't think I wrote it in the happiest of all moods...I think it was wrote right before the rock bottom period of my life that happened a few weeks ago so I apologize if it sounds angry. Some of it I have been able to work through since then. There is a lot that comes from my not so positive church experience in the past so in many ways I am ;earning what my view of church is and what the bible says church is supposed to be....but here it is.
"Community
Belonging
To know you can be who you are without any pretending. Although you might not agree with everyone, you are accepted.
The Church is the Christian community. In theory it should emphasize this feeling of belonging but it along with the rest of the world is extraordinarily broken and is often unable to meet the needs of its members.
I’m a Christian. Jesus is my life. I am part of the body of Christ. Supposedly everyone is needed. A hand can’t say to a foot, ‘I don’t need you’. But sometimes I still feel like I do not fit into the church. Sometimes I feel like such an outsider. Where did my view of the church get as distorted as the view of my own body?
When did I suddenly feel the need to put up a wall that doesn’t let anyone into my emotions, including myself? Why can’t I feel anymore? Why can’t I cry? "
"My life is full of ‘shoulds’ that I never seem to be living up to.
I ‘should’ be trusting Jesus to get me through.
I ‘should’ be able to get through this with him alone, never needing to depend on anyone else.
I ‘should’ be able to eat when I am hungry.
I ‘should’ be an adult right now and holding my own job and paying my own rent.
I ‘should’ be putting myself aside to help others because other people’s problems are far greater than my own.
A religion that ‘should’ be rooted entirely in grace is rooted for me entirely in rules and laws that I just can’t fit into and that I can’t escape."
"Even admitting this to others just seems so wrong. I have a strong need for affirmation and validation and simply to be touched and to be held. Maybe it is my own distortion of the church or maybe it is what I have been taught but having these needs seems like the ultimate sin. I might as well have sex before marriage or commit a murder because these sins seem like they are far more easily forgivable than the sin of emotional neediness."
"How do I achieve the freedom that Christianity advertises? I want nothing in this world but to serve Jesus Christ, however, I ultimately seem to fail at this over and over again.
Starvation has become my Novocain for life. By concentrating on the hunger in my stomach I can block out everything else. I desperately want to seek help from others, to pour out my heart and soul to them, but that in the rules of the Christianity that I have been taught is just wrong. I ‘should’ be selfless and concentrating on the needs of others. I ‘should’ be relying completely on Jesus to meet my needs."
"However, even the most rigid of Christians will admit that life isn’t perfect all the time. Sometimes it’s ok to seek help and support for awhile. People will offer a hug or be willing to talk occasionally. But what happens when the problem and the pain is deeper than that, so deep that I can’t even voice it because it is so utterly icky and gross? Eventually people want you to get out of your “pity party” and stand on your own two feet. They get tired of you and your “emotional neediness” and set you aside as ‘one of them’.
An outsider.
A leper.
You are sent to a therapist to “get fixed.” Specialized centers are to provide all the care. When you are “better” you will be accepted back into society.
However, I begin to retreat farther and farther into my own brain. If I can create ways of not feeling that pain, actually not feeling at all, I will be far more likely to be accepted."
"But then I am back to that age old question, when is just being me enough? At what point do I no longer have to prove myself worthy of love?"
"Practically every Christian would say, ‘You don’t have to do anything. God loves you just the way you are.’ But that is just head knowledge. I think few actually believe this by the way they live their lives. It’s all about doing. When we should be walking side by side with each other, I look around to what seems like a race to be the best. In the secular world it is who can be the most successful or who can make the most money, but in the Christian community that I see it is almost a fight to be the best Christian. To give the most, to serve the most, to lead as many people to Jesus, even to be the most ‘humble’. Love doesn’t’ seem to be the rock that all our actions are rooted in anymore."
"And again, just writing that causes the hammers in my brain to come down even heavier as I get screamed at for being too negative. I want to love as Jesus loved, but I feel so unbelievably terrible at it."
"Looking around this city, I see a bunch of robotic people who don’t even question life anymore. I long to break down some of the walls and bubbles that chain us down and just get back to the simplicity of love."
"I don’t know where I went wrong. I want to love myself again. I want to believe that God loves me without me doing anything. I want to show people that they can belong. Frankly, I want to belong too. "
"Community group is my favorite parts of the week. I can see honest, open, and non-judgmental conversations going on. However, that is only for a few hours a week...I am slowly learning the importance of living out community every day. "
"I need the church. I need community. I need to see truth because if the Christianity I see is truth, I am forever doomed to Hell."
"I need love, not criticism or judgment. I need grace, not contempt. I need to see truth, but lies are what continually rule in my head.
I want these chains to be gone. I want to be the me I was a year ago, but purified through the reality of grace. I don’t want to care about weight and fat and calories and mirrors and what is ok to eat and what is not ok. I want to feel. I want to let go. I want to wipe the pretend smile off and just be real. I want to laugh. I want to be held until the pain and hurt go away.
I want to say good bye to the therapists.
I want to live in community."
"I hate that I hate myself. I hate how alone I feel. I hate everything about me. I never would have begun to say that a year ago. I hate how I seem to need my emotions to be validated. I hate that I am not trusting Jesus enough. I hate feeling so vulnerable and I hate that I can’t seem to communicate with others at all. I hate my neediness.
I hate asking for help and once I finally do I tend to run away from it. I just need to hear from someone that this isn’t my fault "
I actually wrote the following awhile back in the midst of the counselor crisis...so some of it may be overlapping a little bit of what I have already said...
It might be slightly even more intense than normal entries because I don't think I wrote it in the happiest of all moods...I think it was wrote right before the rock bottom period of my life that happened a few weeks ago so I apologize if it sounds angry. Some of it I have been able to work through since then. There is a lot that comes from my not so positive church experience in the past so in many ways I am ;earning what my view of church is and what the bible says church is supposed to be....but here it is.
"Community
Belonging
To know you can be who you are without any pretending. Although you might not agree with everyone, you are accepted.
The Church is the Christian community. In theory it should emphasize this feeling of belonging but it along with the rest of the world is extraordinarily broken and is often unable to meet the needs of its members.
I’m a Christian. Jesus is my life. I am part of the body of Christ. Supposedly everyone is needed. A hand can’t say to a foot, ‘I don’t need you’. But sometimes I still feel like I do not fit into the church. Sometimes I feel like such an outsider. Where did my view of the church get as distorted as the view of my own body?
When did I suddenly feel the need to put up a wall that doesn’t let anyone into my emotions, including myself? Why can’t I feel anymore? Why can’t I cry? "
"My life is full of ‘shoulds’ that I never seem to be living up to.
I ‘should’ be trusting Jesus to get me through.
I ‘should’ be able to get through this with him alone, never needing to depend on anyone else.
I ‘should’ be able to eat when I am hungry.
I ‘should’ be an adult right now and holding my own job and paying my own rent.
I ‘should’ be putting myself aside to help others because other people’s problems are far greater than my own.
A religion that ‘should’ be rooted entirely in grace is rooted for me entirely in rules and laws that I just can’t fit into and that I can’t escape."
"Even admitting this to others just seems so wrong. I have a strong need for affirmation and validation and simply to be touched and to be held. Maybe it is my own distortion of the church or maybe it is what I have been taught but having these needs seems like the ultimate sin. I might as well have sex before marriage or commit a murder because these sins seem like they are far more easily forgivable than the sin of emotional neediness."
"How do I achieve the freedom that Christianity advertises? I want nothing in this world but to serve Jesus Christ, however, I ultimately seem to fail at this over and over again.
Starvation has become my Novocain for life. By concentrating on the hunger in my stomach I can block out everything else. I desperately want to seek help from others, to pour out my heart and soul to them, but that in the rules of the Christianity that I have been taught is just wrong. I ‘should’ be selfless and concentrating on the needs of others. I ‘should’ be relying completely on Jesus to meet my needs."
"However, even the most rigid of Christians will admit that life isn’t perfect all the time. Sometimes it’s ok to seek help and support for awhile. People will offer a hug or be willing to talk occasionally. But what happens when the problem and the pain is deeper than that, so deep that I can’t even voice it because it is so utterly icky and gross? Eventually people want you to get out of your “pity party” and stand on your own two feet. They get tired of you and your “emotional neediness” and set you aside as ‘one of them’.
An outsider.
A leper.
You are sent to a therapist to “get fixed.” Specialized centers are to provide all the care. When you are “better” you will be accepted back into society.
However, I begin to retreat farther and farther into my own brain. If I can create ways of not feeling that pain, actually not feeling at all, I will be far more likely to be accepted."
"But then I am back to that age old question, when is just being me enough? At what point do I no longer have to prove myself worthy of love?"
"Practically every Christian would say, ‘You don’t have to do anything. God loves you just the way you are.’ But that is just head knowledge. I think few actually believe this by the way they live their lives. It’s all about doing. When we should be walking side by side with each other, I look around to what seems like a race to be the best. In the secular world it is who can be the most successful or who can make the most money, but in the Christian community that I see it is almost a fight to be the best Christian. To give the most, to serve the most, to lead as many people to Jesus, even to be the most ‘humble’. Love doesn’t’ seem to be the rock that all our actions are rooted in anymore."
"And again, just writing that causes the hammers in my brain to come down even heavier as I get screamed at for being too negative. I want to love as Jesus loved, but I feel so unbelievably terrible at it."
"Looking around this city, I see a bunch of robotic people who don’t even question life anymore. I long to break down some of the walls and bubbles that chain us down and just get back to the simplicity of love."
"I don’t know where I went wrong. I want to love myself again. I want to believe that God loves me without me doing anything. I want to show people that they can belong. Frankly, I want to belong too. "
"Community group is my favorite parts of the week. I can see honest, open, and non-judgmental conversations going on. However, that is only for a few hours a week...I am slowly learning the importance of living out community every day. "
"I need the church. I need community. I need to see truth because if the Christianity I see is truth, I am forever doomed to Hell."
"I need love, not criticism or judgment. I need grace, not contempt. I need to see truth, but lies are what continually rule in my head.
I want these chains to be gone. I want to be the me I was a year ago, but purified through the reality of grace. I don’t want to care about weight and fat and calories and mirrors and what is ok to eat and what is not ok. I want to feel. I want to let go. I want to wipe the pretend smile off and just be real. I want to laugh. I want to be held until the pain and hurt go away.
I want to say good bye to the therapists.
I want to live in community."
"I hate that I hate myself. I hate how alone I feel. I hate everything about me. I never would have begun to say that a year ago. I hate how I seem to need my emotions to be validated. I hate that I am not trusting Jesus enough. I hate feeling so vulnerable and I hate that I can’t seem to communicate with others at all. I hate my neediness.
I hate asking for help and once I finally do I tend to run away from it. I just need to hear from someone that this isn’t my fault "
Friday, April 10, 2009
A caring community
This is kind of a continuation from the last post on my frustrations with the professionalization of care in America.
I feel like people have just sent me to specialized people to get "fixed". Everyday ordinary people have become extremlely wary of talking to me or offering any sort of wisdom or advice. The most common statement I get from the people I confess my life to is "I wish there was something I could do for you." This kind of closes me off to people in general because I know I am just letting everyone else into this cycle of guilt because me telling them I am having problems does nothing for either one of us besides make them feel bad that they can't do anything. If they do begin to offer any sort of advice it is normally pointing me to a therapist.
So I do know that this is something that the average person does not feel comfortable talking about...it is an awkward subject that can cause anyone to squirm again. Believe me...I know...I am living it.
But I feel deep in my heart that hiding is no longer the answer *hence the web blog*. I am sick of hiding behind the pretend smile that everyone wants to see. I'm afraid of letting the real me that has problems show because I know it will be rejected....but this is the fear that every single girl with an eating disorder in America hides behind....and I don't think it even goes for eating disorders alone...anyone who has a problem that doesn't have a quick fix solution, namely every single one of us in this world at one point or another in our lives.
A while ago, after beginning to realize that therapists were not working out for me (and I wasn't really working for the therapists), I started questioning what I was looking for. Why did I feel so alone? Why was nothing changing? Would things ever change?
I didn't have complete answers to these questions but I came to the conclusion that I just was looking for someone who cared. Now part of this is Ana just screaming constantly, "No one cares about you" but some of it was rooted in reality that I was facing...especially in terms of the Christian church (at least in this country) in that we have been taught not to care....or maybe this is just my church experience. This isn't completely true I guess, we pick and choose what we care about. We care about things that have easy solutions...we like concrete things that we can put an answer with....when it comes to complicated matters of the heart, the therapists are called.
However, I am realizing I am becoming the guinea pig to find a solution to my own problem. Somewhere inside of me I know I am not alone in my desire to be cared for and to live in community...we all have problems that we hide behind, feeling like no one else could possibly understand our pain. Some of this is true, sometimes Jesus really is the only one that can fully sympathize with what we are going through. However, if I have learned anything throughout all of this it is that the biggest lie Satan throws at us is that we are meant to do this alone. God gave us other people in our life to learn from and to help each other grow closer to him.
Peter Block writes about community, “We are in community each time we find a place where we belong…belong is to be related and to be a part of something. It is membership, the experience of being at home in the broad sense of the phrase. It is the opposite of thinking that wherever I am, I would be better off somewhere else. Or that I am still forever wandering, looking for that place where I belong…to belong is to know, even in the middle of the night, that I am among friends.”
Now how amazing does that sound?
Henri Nouwen writes in his book Life of the Beloved, “As the elevator took us to the eleventh floor, I felt an eerie silence among the passengers who were almost elbow to elbow. How close and yet how far apart.”
I have felt the very same way riding on the T....looking around at the faces that refuse to even make eye contact with you, for fear of being caught off guard and showing their vulnerability.
Again...more questions than answers....and I have a whole lot more to ramble on about....but trying to keep things in semi small chunks so that is it for now.
I feel like people have just sent me to specialized people to get "fixed". Everyday ordinary people have become extremlely wary of talking to me or offering any sort of wisdom or advice. The most common statement I get from the people I confess my life to is "I wish there was something I could do for you." This kind of closes me off to people in general because I know I am just letting everyone else into this cycle of guilt because me telling them I am having problems does nothing for either one of us besides make them feel bad that they can't do anything. If they do begin to offer any sort of advice it is normally pointing me to a therapist.
So I do know that this is something that the average person does not feel comfortable talking about...it is an awkward subject that can cause anyone to squirm again. Believe me...I know...I am living it.
But I feel deep in my heart that hiding is no longer the answer *hence the web blog*. I am sick of hiding behind the pretend smile that everyone wants to see. I'm afraid of letting the real me that has problems show because I know it will be rejected....but this is the fear that every single girl with an eating disorder in America hides behind....and I don't think it even goes for eating disorders alone...anyone who has a problem that doesn't have a quick fix solution, namely every single one of us in this world at one point or another in our lives.
A while ago, after beginning to realize that therapists were not working out for me (and I wasn't really working for the therapists), I started questioning what I was looking for. Why did I feel so alone? Why was nothing changing? Would things ever change?
I didn't have complete answers to these questions but I came to the conclusion that I just was looking for someone who cared. Now part of this is Ana just screaming constantly, "No one cares about you" but some of it was rooted in reality that I was facing...especially in terms of the Christian church (at least in this country) in that we have been taught not to care....or maybe this is just my church experience. This isn't completely true I guess, we pick and choose what we care about. We care about things that have easy solutions...we like concrete things that we can put an answer with....when it comes to complicated matters of the heart, the therapists are called.
However, I am realizing I am becoming the guinea pig to find a solution to my own problem. Somewhere inside of me I know I am not alone in my desire to be cared for and to live in community...we all have problems that we hide behind, feeling like no one else could possibly understand our pain. Some of this is true, sometimes Jesus really is the only one that can fully sympathize with what we are going through. However, if I have learned anything throughout all of this it is that the biggest lie Satan throws at us is that we are meant to do this alone. God gave us other people in our life to learn from and to help each other grow closer to him.
Peter Block writes about community, “We are in community each time we find a place where we belong…belong is to be related and to be a part of something. It is membership, the experience of being at home in the broad sense of the phrase. It is the opposite of thinking that wherever I am, I would be better off somewhere else. Or that I am still forever wandering, looking for that place where I belong…to belong is to know, even in the middle of the night, that I am among friends.”
Now how amazing does that sound?
Henri Nouwen writes in his book Life of the Beloved, “As the elevator took us to the eleventh floor, I felt an eerie silence among the passengers who were almost elbow to elbow. How close and yet how far apart.”
I have felt the very same way riding on the T....looking around at the faces that refuse to even make eye contact with you, for fear of being caught off guard and showing their vulnerability.
Again...more questions than answers....and I have a whole lot more to ramble on about....but trying to keep things in semi small chunks so that is it for now.
Thursday, April 9, 2009
The Counselor Crisis
I'm realizing more and more that this is a really intense blog...which I strongly apologize for anyone out there that may be reading this. And I kind of want to send out a note that in daily life I am not nearly this intense of a person. The past year has been pretty intense in general, but overall in life I tend to be pretty light hearted and filled with laughter. This has just become my out to get rid of some of those crazy thoughts that stream through my head.
With that said...on to another intense conversation of me venting of how much I despise counselors (not the people themselves, just the profession). From the very beginning they were far more frustrating to me than the eating thing itself. I distinctly remember one of my eariler conversations with Dr. Brubaker (the medical doctor at Houghton)...as he tried to work his way up to the point of introducing the idea to me, "I know that this is going to be the hardest thing for you. But I think it is important to consider. Would you be willing to go to the counseling center?" ...Which I responded with a squirm and a response of 'No way.' I did not like the stigma that a counselor would bring. I relied on Jesus to meet all my needs...I didn't need to talk to a therapist. I was not crazy. (This theory was later proven way wrong but I am not going to get into that now)
Unfortunately, when you go to a small Christian college, of course the doctor and the counselor are good friends so Dr. Brubaker actually left me in the office as he went to the counseling center to see if he could get me an appointment.
In the past year now I have been to 4 different counselors and three of them have dumped me in one way or another. Every appointment I have gone to I have left far more frustrated than when I came. People tell me things like "Counseling isn't easy." and "Sometimes its just hard to find the right fit but you should try again." Quite frankly, when counselors abandon you, you start losing trust in all people. I have poured out so much of my life to these people and have become extremely vulnerable and when they just stop talking to me, they leave me alone.. but take all that I have told them with them. In the end I am left very hurt and the wounds that were already there just deepen. Well, as of yesterday I am officially done with counselors (although this is the one relationship that I ended and not the other way around).
The one that I just left just creeped me out a little, although he was a nice guy. I think all of my past experiences with counselors didn't help matters but I just could not communicate with him. I did ask him if I could see someone else at the center but he told me that he had already asked around but no one felt comfortable taking me on...ha.
I don't want to bash counselors completely because I know they have done wonders for other people, it just was not a right fit for me. Anytime I would walk into one of their offices I would just freeze, feeling radically uncomfortable pouring out the ickiest part of my life on a complete stranger. The thing I hated the most though is that I felt like I was almost talking to a subhuman robot....someone who had their own life completely together and couldn't relate at all with the pain that I was going through. In some ways they did nothing but make me feel tremendously more inadequate. I know it was supposed to be a "professional" relationship and counselors are taught not to talk about their personal lives, but without some self disclosure on their part, how am I supposed to be comfortable telling them my life story? I hate being that vulnerable with someone and I hate relationships that are just me taking from them, feeling I have nothing to give.
Often times because of this, I get nowhere with these people that I spend an incredibly awkward hour a week with. I just shut off completely and they do all the talking. I don't have answers for their questions but often times I understand a lot more than they think I do...I just can't communicate this.
However, I still meet with my doctor every other week and I wouldn't describe our relationship that way at all. Although it can still be awkward and he asks questions that I don't have answers for, he creates a safe environment for me to talk to him and actually makes it quite clear that he is human, which is great to know. The relationship is still professional but he occasionally tells me things that he has been through in his own life that relate to some of my struggles, so not only does he let me know that he is imperfect as well, he gives me hope that there is light at the end of the tunnel.
My real issue with all of this is the "professionalization of care". We have all heard it talked about occasionally in church or other places but I have seen it lived out in my everyday life and that has been by far the most painful thing about this eating disorder. I just feel like I am shipped from one person to the other. No one feels "qualified" to talk to me and a few of my friends have been told to "stop caring" and to "leave her to the professionals." Again, I don't want to say that professionals can't help because both my doctor and nutritionist have helped a great deal but I feel as a church as a whole we are called to take care of each other but it seems like the church in america has lost what care really is.
“To care means first of all to be present to each other. From experience, you know that those who care for you become present to you. When they listen, they listen to you. When they speak, you know they speak to you. And when they ask questions, you know it is for your sake and not their own. Their presence is a healing presence because they accept you on your terms and they encourage you to take your own life seriously and to trust your own vocation.” ~ Henri Nouwen
“Our tendency is to run away from the painful realities or to try to change them as soon as possible. But cure without care makes us into rulers, controllers, manipulators and prevents a real community from taking shape. Cure without care makes us preoccupied with quick changes, impatient and unwilling to share each others burden. And so cure can often become offending instead of liberating. It is therefore not so strange that cure is not seldom refused by people in need. Not only have individuals refused help when they did not sense a real care, but also oppressed minorities have resisted support, and suffering nations have declined medicine and food when they realized that it was better to suffer than to lose self-respect by accepting a gift out of a non-caring hand.” ~Henri Nouwen
I have a lot more to say on this but my blogs are already too long as it is so I will continue later on...
With that said...on to another intense conversation of me venting of how much I despise counselors (not the people themselves, just the profession). From the very beginning they were far more frustrating to me than the eating thing itself. I distinctly remember one of my eariler conversations with Dr. Brubaker (the medical doctor at Houghton)...as he tried to work his way up to the point of introducing the idea to me, "I know that this is going to be the hardest thing for you. But I think it is important to consider. Would you be willing to go to the counseling center?" ...Which I responded with a squirm and a response of 'No way.' I did not like the stigma that a counselor would bring. I relied on Jesus to meet all my needs...I didn't need to talk to a therapist. I was not crazy. (This theory was later proven way wrong but I am not going to get into that now)
Unfortunately, when you go to a small Christian college, of course the doctor and the counselor are good friends so Dr. Brubaker actually left me in the office as he went to the counseling center to see if he could get me an appointment.
In the past year now I have been to 4 different counselors and three of them have dumped me in one way or another. Every appointment I have gone to I have left far more frustrated than when I came. People tell me things like "Counseling isn't easy." and "Sometimes its just hard to find the right fit but you should try again." Quite frankly, when counselors abandon you, you start losing trust in all people. I have poured out so much of my life to these people and have become extremely vulnerable and when they just stop talking to me, they leave me alone.. but take all that I have told them with them. In the end I am left very hurt and the wounds that were already there just deepen. Well, as of yesterday I am officially done with counselors (although this is the one relationship that I ended and not the other way around).
The one that I just left just creeped me out a little, although he was a nice guy. I think all of my past experiences with counselors didn't help matters but I just could not communicate with him. I did ask him if I could see someone else at the center but he told me that he had already asked around but no one felt comfortable taking me on...ha.
I don't want to bash counselors completely because I know they have done wonders for other people, it just was not a right fit for me. Anytime I would walk into one of their offices I would just freeze, feeling radically uncomfortable pouring out the ickiest part of my life on a complete stranger. The thing I hated the most though is that I felt like I was almost talking to a subhuman robot....someone who had their own life completely together and couldn't relate at all with the pain that I was going through. In some ways they did nothing but make me feel tremendously more inadequate. I know it was supposed to be a "professional" relationship and counselors are taught not to talk about their personal lives, but without some self disclosure on their part, how am I supposed to be comfortable telling them my life story? I hate being that vulnerable with someone and I hate relationships that are just me taking from them, feeling I have nothing to give.
Often times because of this, I get nowhere with these people that I spend an incredibly awkward hour a week with. I just shut off completely and they do all the talking. I don't have answers for their questions but often times I understand a lot more than they think I do...I just can't communicate this.
However, I still meet with my doctor every other week and I wouldn't describe our relationship that way at all. Although it can still be awkward and he asks questions that I don't have answers for, he creates a safe environment for me to talk to him and actually makes it quite clear that he is human, which is great to know. The relationship is still professional but he occasionally tells me things that he has been through in his own life that relate to some of my struggles, so not only does he let me know that he is imperfect as well, he gives me hope that there is light at the end of the tunnel.
My real issue with all of this is the "professionalization of care". We have all heard it talked about occasionally in church or other places but I have seen it lived out in my everyday life and that has been by far the most painful thing about this eating disorder. I just feel like I am shipped from one person to the other. No one feels "qualified" to talk to me and a few of my friends have been told to "stop caring" and to "leave her to the professionals." Again, I don't want to say that professionals can't help because both my doctor and nutritionist have helped a great deal but I feel as a church as a whole we are called to take care of each other but it seems like the church in america has lost what care really is.
“To care means first of all to be present to each other. From experience, you know that those who care for you become present to you. When they listen, they listen to you. When they speak, you know they speak to you. And when they ask questions, you know it is for your sake and not their own. Their presence is a healing presence because they accept you on your terms and they encourage you to take your own life seriously and to trust your own vocation.” ~ Henri Nouwen
“Our tendency is to run away from the painful realities or to try to change them as soon as possible. But cure without care makes us into rulers, controllers, manipulators and prevents a real community from taking shape. Cure without care makes us preoccupied with quick changes, impatient and unwilling to share each others burden. And so cure can often become offending instead of liberating. It is therefore not so strange that cure is not seldom refused by people in need. Not only have individuals refused help when they did not sense a real care, but also oppressed minorities have resisted support, and suffering nations have declined medicine and food when they realized that it was better to suffer than to lose self-respect by accepting a gift out of a non-caring hand.” ~Henri Nouwen
I have a lot more to say on this but my blogs are already too long as it is so I will continue later on...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)